Finding the right real estate agent can make or break your buying or selling experience. The best agents don’t just open doors — they educate you, communicate clearly, and protect your interests from the first showing to the closing table.
But with thousands of agents to choose from, how do you know who’s actually the right fit for you? Here’s what to look for, plus how a referral agent can help you take the guesswork out of the process entirely.
The Four Qualities of a Great Real Estate Agent
1. Local Experience and Market Knowledge
A strong agent knows their local market inside and out — pricing trends, school districts, upcoming developments, and even which neighborhoods sell faster than others. They’ll use this insight to help you make informed decisions, whether that’s structuring a competitive offer or pricing your home strategically.
2. Communication and Responsiveness
Your agent should be someone who keeps you informed every step of the way. Real estate moves quickly, and a delay in communication can mean missing out on your dream home or the best buyer. Look for an agent who replies promptly, provides updates without being asked, and takes the time to explain every step in plain language.
3. Strategy and Negotiation Skills
Great REALTORS® don’t just react to the market — they plan for it. Ask how they prepare buyers for multiple-offer situations or how they market homes to attract strong, qualified buyers. Their ability to negotiate terms, timelines, and contingencies can directly impact your bottom line.
4. Trust and Personality Fit
You’ll spend a lot of time communicating with your agent. You want someone whose approach and personality complement yours. Whether you prefer a data-driven negotiator or a patient advisor, the right fit makes the experience more enjoyable and less stressful.
Example: The First-Time Buyer Choosing Between Two Agents
Meet Sarah, a first-time homebuyer moving from an apartment into her first house. She interviews two agents: one who seems friendly but vague, and another who provides detailed next steps, a preapproval checklist, and local market stats.
The difference? Preparation. The second agent gives Sarah confidence and clarity — qualities that matter even more than personality alone. With help from a referral agent, she found someone who already had a strong record working with first-time buyers in her price range and area.
Example: The Seller Choosing Who to List With
Now meet Tom and Amanda, homeowners preparing to sell their property before relocating for work. They interview multiple listing agents: one promises the highest price but offers little data to back it up, while another provides a full comparative market analysis, marketing plan, and realistic timeline.
With guidance from a referral agent, they choose the second REALTOR® — someone who had proven results in their neighborhood. Their home sells quickly, with multiple offers, and closes before their move.
Why Using a Referral Agent Simplifies the Search
Choosing an agent on your own can feel overwhelming. A licensed referral agent eliminates that uncertainty by doing the legwork for you.
Here’s how it works:
- They start by learning your goals, preferences, and timeline.
- They vet local agents using production data, reviews, and reputation.
- You receive one or more introductions to REALTORS® who already fit your needs.
- You choose who to work with — no pressure, no obligation.
This personalized matchmaking process ensures you’re connected with professionals who are experienced, communicative, and trustworthy — without spending hours researching online.
One-Month Trial Match:
When you’re introduced to your matched REALTOR®, you’ll begin with a one-month trial agreement. This gives you and your agent time to work together, make sure the partnership feels like a great fit, and ensures you’re supported by someone who communicates well and understands your goals — before committing long-term.
How Referral Fees Work
There’s no upfront cost to you. If you choose to work with the agent we match you with and your home purchase or sale successfully closes, a portion of that agent’s commission is paid to your referral agent.
It’s a system that rewards quality and accountability — because your referral agent succeeds only when you do.
Questions to Ask When Interviewing an Agent
If you’re ready to start interviewing REALTORS®, ask:
- How many clients have you represented in the past year?
- What’s your average list-to-sale price ratio or days on market?
- How do you prefer to communicate with clients?
- What’s your strategy for pricing (if selling) or winning offers (if buying)?
- Can I see reviews or testimonials from recent clients?
These questions will help you identify professionalism, experience, and communication style — three pillars of a great agent-client relationship.
Ready to Get Matched?
Take our short quiz to get matched with a trusted local REALTOR® anywhere in the U.S. You’ll receive your personalized introductions within 1–2 business days and clear next steps to move forward.
About the Author:
Chelsea Vanderpool is a Licensed Referral Agent and Property Manager with Weichert REALTORS®, Mark Thomas Properties. She helps home buyers, sellers, and investors across the U.S. connect with trusted local agents through personalized referrals.
Stay Connected:
Want practical tips on choosing agents, navigating offers, and understanding market shifts? Subscribe for helpful guides and nationwide insights delivered to your inbox.